The race for Islamorada Council: Candidates talk plans for village properties, Amendment 3

Four seats on the Islamorada Village Council are up for election in November. Running for the seats are eight candidates hoping to serve residents.

Now through Election Day, the Upper Keys Weekly will ask the candidates about a variety of topics in the village.

**The Upper Keys Weekly asked the candidates: **

  1. If elected, what actions would you take in your first term as it relates to the former Island Silver & Spice and Island Community Church properties?
  2. What cost-cutting measures would you undertake next budget cycle, if Amendment 3 passes in November?

(Answers are printed exactly as submitted by candidates, with responses limited to 200 words).

Seat 1

Anna Richards

1. These properties are major investments of taxpayer dollars, we have a responsibility to ensure that we first use their money in wise, sound decisions. I would like to see action taken on the Island Silver and Spice property with a combination of different uses as the property is large enough. I would like for more community input, but possibly some Village center uses with affordable housing above leaving room for parking and green space. We need to search out grant funding once we decide on a feasible plan.

The Island Community Church property is costing taxpayers many dollars to sit vacant and too much to fix it, if we could sell it and put the money back into reserves or purchase property that is environmentally sensitive for conservation.

2.The budget discussion would need to start earlier than this year and address both the initial revenue reduction and its possible effects. A complete department by department examination as I did this year, and will continue to do so. We can look at overtime, operating expenses, staffing which I believe staff did a very thorough detail on this year in cutting many expenses along with council. We have to review carrying costs for all properties, review existing vendor agreements, and always pursuing as many grants as possible. I have sent the grants opportunities that I find interesting to Environmental, parks and recreation, fire rescue departments and most of them the staff has already seen and working on which shows how much they are looking out for residents.

Joe Wischmeier

1. I believe that one of the biggest needs in Islamorada is workforce housing. The key word here is “workforce.” I just attended the workshop on our new comprehensive plan and one of the studies showed that over 80% of people who work in Islamorada commute from other areas including the mainland. This not only is a burden on our workforce but adds to our traffic congestion. One example of this is teachers. My wife has been a teacher at Coral Shores High School for over 30 years. In that time many people have come down to apply for openings thinking what a great place to work. I can educate our children and live in paradise. Wow! Then they get here and find out that they cannot find an affordable place to live. Many of our businesses are struggling because they cannot find workers. This trend has got to change. By using these properties to create truly affordable workforce housing for people who work in Islamorada, we can demonstrate to them that we really care.

2. The first thing that I would do is to form a citizen task force like the one that we had last year to examine and make suggestions about budget cutting ideas. We have some very smart people in our community that volunteered their time and found many ways to do that. Next the council should have a complete DOGE type audit done to find areas where cost cutting ideas can be implemented. Other communities have had this done with great success. Then it would be incumbent on all department heads to find ways to cut at least 10% from their budgets without cutting services. I would suggest that a good place to start would be overtime hours. They need to manage their time to optimize efficiency. We have all had the make sacrifices in the past to make sure we can meet our financial burdens. Now is the time for Islamorada to do the same thing. By implementing these ideas I believe that we can trim the budget without cutting services.

Seat 2

Steve Friedman

1. These are Village owned properties. The community should have the most say in what actions should be taken. We want to see more public participation and input into what we might do on our village owned properties. S&S is ideally located in a central area of Islamorada which lends itself to be an opportunity for a city center/transportation/expo/food truck location. Ideally, or for example, we should retain ownership of the church property and invite entities that are community minded, that could possibly come in to remodel and lease the property long term.

2. I’ve suggested holding at least quarterly workshops with the staff and community members to go over the budget, line by line, and begin the process of cutting where we can without eliminating amenities or staff. HB 1329 already requires local officials to identify ways we can reduce the budget by 10% without reducing essential services. This is an exercise we should’ve already been implementing.

Deb Gillis

  1. Both properties need a clearly defined purpose if they are to remain Village-owned. Moving

these properties forward has been difficult, but after several years, I believe it is overdue for us to develop realistic plans for their future. When properties are purchased with public funds, the

Village should have a plan for how they will serve the community and how their costs will be supported.

The former Island Silver & Spice property has been vacant for more than three years, making it an expensive Village asset to leave underutilized. I would stress a mixed-use concept with paid parking on the ground level, shops, offices or a community center on the second floor, and workforce housing on the top floor. I am open to other ideas, but believe the Village should actively develop potential uses and begin implementing paid parking to generate revenue.

For the former Island Community Church property, I would evaluate the substantial repairs needed against its potential community benefit. I would support exploring a sale or long-term lease if that is the most responsible use.

2. If Amendment 3 passes, my first step would be to determine its actual impact on Islamorada’s revenues before making any cuts. Because the amendment is progressive, we also need to evaluate its potential impact in future years and include those projections in our long-term financial planning.

I would direct staff to conduct a department-by-department review of ongoing operating expenses and identify opportunities to reduce costs without compromising public safety, essential services or our environmental responsibilities. I would look closely at vacant positions, overtime, professional contracts, purchasing, technology, vehicles and equipment, and fringe benefits for potential savings. I would also review programs that may duplicate services provided by the County or other agencies.

At the same time, we should actively pursue additional grant opportunities and partnerships to help supplement available funding and support needed projects. I would also review Village-owned property expenses and opportunities to generate appropriate revenue. Most importantly, we should protect essential services while requiring every department to justify its expenditures. Good budgeting means setting priorities, finding efficiencies, seeking additional funding and avoiding unnecessary increases in ongoing operating costs.

Seat 3

Corie McGraw-Abel

1. Both the Island Silver and Spice property and the Island Christian Church property are valuable and belong to the taxpayers. That being said, I agree with the Island Christian Church property being offered for sale. It wasn’t a planned purchase, and the money should be returned to the general fund.

Due to the central location of the Island Silver and Spice property and the size, I would suggest it be used as a combination of community use, parking and maybe even some workforce housing. Much of what can be done with the property will depend on what type of funding/grants are available for what is allowed on the property.

2. If Amendment 3 passes, it will be important to work with staff and the public to understand what departments might need work. Once there is a general understanding of how the budget looks after Amendment 3, we could work together to make the most strategic fiscal adjustments, keeping in mind the importance of public safety, essential infrastructure, and services residents depend on.

Sue Miller

  1. Significant funds have been used to acquire these properties and still no plan. The Actions and Policies Status Report has a “Village-Owned Properties Workshop” listed as requested by Council in 2025. And yet “Not currently scheduled.”

I think it is the residents and taxpayers who should have a significant voice in this issue. They should be involved in the plan. A decision to put up a “For Sale” sign on the church property was done without involving the public. A simple thumbs up from some members of council provided staff with direction to put up a “for sale” sign.

I would expect to see an agenda item for a public meeting or workshop listing the pros and cons describing whether the Village needs the property, the best use, a value analysis, conditions of the property, so council can make a more informed decision with public involvement.

2. Amendment 3 or not… It is critical that we take an in-depth look at why our taxes go up so much every year without any noticeable expansion in services. We desperately need to cut wasteful spending. We need more transparency. There should be monthly finance reports showing a summary, department by department, as to the revenues and expenditures compared to the approved budget.

We need to encourage competitive bidding, not continually waive it. Do we utilize continuing service contracts to hire favored contractors without receiving competitive proposals? I regularly review line-item revenue and expenditure detail, obtained via public record requests. I am always shocked at what I see. The small wasteful spending adds up quickly. Big items even quicker. The Florida Department of Government Efficiency (DOGE) was created with a primary mission to eliminate unnecessary spending, maximize productivity, and ensure accountability in state agencies including municipalities. We need to endorse that mission.

The state has put out a manual “How To Doge Yourself.” It is an excellent guide to establish the goal of delivering government efficiencies to which citizens are entitled. Taxpayers are paying far too much. We must fix it before more valued residents leave Islamorada.

Seat 4

Don Horton

1. The Island Silver property is a diamond in the rough. I see no need to hurry, but I see a wonderful opportunity to have a combination of workforce housing and boutique businesses with a space for Village events. I believe a redevelopment of the business district with private and public funds will draw residents as well as visitors to our downtown corridor and the arts district. As for the ICC property, I am hopeful we will be able to monetize this property to offset Property taxes. If I am reelected, I will put both properties to good use for our citizens.

2. I have met with several community leaders and stakeholders to discuss cost-cutting measures. Our Village Manager and I have attended several sessions related to this topic at different Florida League of Cities Conferences. We have also had one-on-one sessions with league leadership to discuss Amendment 3. If this amendment passes, we will have a unique and unprecedented opportunity to re-define governmental operations. Use of Ai will become more prevalent, Likely we will have more online meetings and workshops to cut staff time. Regardless of the outcome of the vote on Amendment 3, I am prepared to work with the Village Manager to effectuate the changes that need to be made, while keeping our citizens in the forefront.

Tom Raffanello

1. To this day, I cannot figure out why we spent $6 million dollars of taxpayer money on real estate for which we had no plan. Both properties have sat vacant for several years. Current council continues to leave them unoccupied without explaining their intent. We have asked the village for a plan on several occasions.

A short time later a homemade “for sale” sign appeared at the vacant church — no identification of who is representing the village or if it is for sale by owner.

The church needs significant repairs before sale, compounding the question of why we purchased it.

Why did we buy it or the Island Spice property? This is another half-baked decision that drains our tax money. When elected, I will immediately initiate a working group of residents to propose uses or a plan to properly market or trade these properties. The public does not even know if we have a real estate group working for us and the sale.

Are we represented and by whom? It’s our tax money and we should have these questions answered. We have many talented residents with diverse experience, ideas and vision. Let’s solicit input and then critically, make a decision. Let’s stop the nonsense and be responsible.

2. The Village of Islamorada has existed more than a quarter century. But we have never conducted an effectiveness audit to determine what Village programs are no longer needed or should be augmented. The Village has two employees (maybe more) that are paid more than the governor. Does that sound fair?

In a prior job, I had to conduct an effectiveness audit every three years to ensure the highest utilization of taxpayer funds. We have experienced an increase in our taxes of 97% over the past 7 years, with a 15% increase in taxes in the last two under current Council. An efficiency audit is the hallmark of an efficient, attentive government. It will also prepare the Village for Amendment 3, if passed.

I would also review our lobbyists’ contract. We have overlapping goals with Marathon and Monroe County, yet all three pay lobbyists separately. We should hire an in-house counsel whose sole focus is Islamorada. We spent over $700,000 last year on contract counsel. Lots of fluff there . . . . We have two “self-sufficient” entities — wastewater and Founders Park marina. But neither has hit that mark. Allegedly, we are borrowing $17 million to make wastewater solvent.

When elected, I will obtain and share a full report of the status of these two “‘self-sufficient” entities — good or bad. Elected officials are public servants and owe their constituents their best. When elected, I pledge to devote my undivided attention to our residents and our special environment.

Subscribe To Our Newsletter

Get Keys Weekly delivered right to your inbox along with a daily dose of Keys News.

Success! Please check your email for confirmation.