The red, white and black notice arrived in the mail the other day, filling me with a bit of hope.
Sure, jury duty reminds us to embrace our role as U.S. citizens; to help maintain law and order and fairly apply the principles of justice in American society — all in service to that whole life- liberty-and-pursuit-of-happiness thing. But also, my last jury summons had led to one of the rarest birds ever seen in North America, mainly because I had strong opinions about native plants.
I’ve been called for jury duty in Key West four or five times over the years. I usually get dismissed for statistical reasons – 100 people show up for a trial that only needs 15 or so jurors. But this time I had made it to voir dire. Typically confined to courtrooms, Law & Order episodes and John Grisham novels, voir dire is the legal process by which defense attorneys and prosecutors question prospective jurors or witnesses to ascertain bias, competence and suitability.
It was a civil trial. Neighbor A sues Neighbor B because Neighbor B had gone onto Neighbor A’s property while they were away and cut down a patch of native trees to improve the view from Neighbor B’s property.
When the defense attorney asked my opinion about such matters, I told the lawyer that chopping down trees on someone else’s property was bad, but chopping down native trees was much worse. Florida Keys ecosystems were facing death by a thousand cuts – a few half-acres here, a few fewer trees there. I told the defense attorney native habitats need protection, and he told me I could leave.
I had already cleared my schedule, in case I was chosen. But my binoculars and camera were in the car — in case I wasn’t.
It was mid-April 2016, the time every spring when migration ramps up, and when rare birds are often discovered. I headed to Fort Zachary Taylor, where I was not surprised to meet up with the small gang of birders who were there most mornings – Carl Goodrich, Lee and Tharon Dunn, and regular out-of-town visitor Murray Gardler.
Carl was the best birder among us, one of the best in the country, in my opinion. People called him the Bird Whisperer as he would find the rare birds everyone else had missed. I would joke that I didn’t need to go out and look for birds, I could just wait for Carl to call.
Lee and Tharon were solid birders too, and generally good company. They walked around the island far more than they drove.
Murray was an exquisite crank, but a sweetheart once he decided you were okay. He’d worked with a lot of car dealerships before retirement and always drove new cars. He and Carl had been friends for years, and Carl told me a story once about them being out birding when Murray realized he’d locked his keys in the car. Instead of calling AAA and waiting around, he just picked up a rock and smashed the driver’s side window, knowing they could put a new one in quick at the local dealers.
Murray was in his later years by this time and set up a lawn chair to stare into a section of the hammock where your skulkier ground specialist species are often seen – gray-cheeked thrushes, Swainson’s thrushes, Swainson’s warblers. Birds that took patience and vigilance to see, and didn’t require much walking. The rest of us roamed around as a pack.
Honestly, I can’t remember what other birds we saw that day, though looking it up on eBird we saw just under 50 species. And I can’t remember how long we roamed. But I do remember finding the bird.
We were working the edge of the entrance road, an area with a lot of trees and bushes. We heard it first – a two-part call with a quick down-up note followed by a quick up-down note. None of us knew what it was, but all of us knew we’d never heard it before. We froze and stared into the same bush.
We could see a shape hopping around a set of branches several layers deep. It looked to be a songbird slightly larger than a warbler.
Then the bird popped out into an open space at the edge of the bush. I raised my camera and caught a few frames. I think Carl did too, and maybe Lee.
The bird was a dull yellow in the belly and gray on top. It had a thick-ish bill and faint wing bars. The most distinctive field mark was a white half circle, like a parenthesis, behind each eye, properly called a postocular crescent.
We all knew it was something we hadn’t seen before. Carl knew what it actually was – a Cuban vireo, a species never recorded in North America, or anywhere outside of Cuba.
After summoning Murray, we all stood huddled on the side of the road, keeping a wary eye on the traffic, but mostly watching the bush to see if the bird popped out again. We had very brief glances of it, but it never exposed itself as clearly as it did in those first moments.
It was the most spectacular unspectacular bird I had ever seen.
We knew we had to put out the word out about what we’d found, but we also knew it would draw small hordes of birders dying to see such a rare thing. And in those small hordes, as in any crowd, a few overzealous people would turn a bird sighting into a life-or-death matter and perhaps inspire them to stray from the trail of acceptable human comportment.
The bird stayed for nearly a week — and lured plenty of people to the state park. There were two or three rude people. They’d shove their head into the bush to flush out the bird. They’d walk up and stand directly in front of us and others to stare into the bush, muttering something about it being a free country. But overall everyone was polite, thoughtful and grateful to see such a bird in such an unlikely place.
Sadly, Murray died a few years after that. Then Tharon a few years later. Carl and Lee both sold their houses here and now spend their time in coastal Massachusetts. But every time I go into the park I still feel I might bump into one of them.
When I called the number on my most recent jury summons I learned they weren’t seating a jury this week. But I might head over to Fort Zachary Taylor in the morning. Just in case.






















