Miami Herald columnist Leonard Pitts, a Pulitzer Prize winner (and remnant of what once was one of our great newspapers), once wrote a column called “Losing the Race for Intelligence.” In it, he compares America with a giant who, while strong and decent, somehow lost its intelligence. This column is a great read and can likely be found in its entirety in the archives at Here is an excerpt from the column:

“Stupidity stole over the giant until it could no longer tell science from faith, or conventional wisdom from actual wisdom and in any event, valued ideological purity above them all. Stupidity snaked over the giant until science teachers shrank from teaching science, history books contained history that wasn’t history, late-night comics got easy laughs from people on the street who could not say when the War of 1812 was fought, political leaders told outright lies with blithe smiles and no fear of being caught and you would not have been surprised to hear that someone had fixed mathematics, so that 2+2 could now equal 17, thus preserving the all-important self esteem of second-grade kids.”

Wow. There is so much truth packed into that paragraph, truth that should give all of us in modern society a reason to pause and reflect. Let’s start with some of our historical religious tomes. The Bible. The Torah. The Quran. (Insert your favorite religious text here.) All of them are classic works, each containing nuggets of spirituality, wisdom, inspiration, poetry, and great insights into the hearts and minds of our ancestors. They’re not science books. They’re not to be used as reference texts for astronomy, paleontology, biology, chemistry, or physics. Yet millions of people in the USA still believe that the Earth is but 6,000 years old, carbon dating is a lie, that vaccines are evil potions, and that the fossil record was put there to test our faith. No matter how much you’d like to, no matter what was written down on 2,000-year-old papyrus from stories handed down the generations, no matter what you think, you can’t invent your own facts!

Politicians, not educators or scientists or historians, often determine what should be taught in classrooms. Society places less value on intellectual exceptionalism than it does on celebrity or athletic skills. A large amount of students don’t care, and why should they? Their parents couldn’t care less, either. And a lot of teachers have to feel frustrated as the importance of education keeps diminishing in the halls of state legislatures nationwide. And while we as a nation seemingly spend a lot on education, our students are ranked but 21st in math proficiency and 26th in science proficiency.

So as we sit with one thumb on the remote control (you know where the other one is), other nations are passing us by. We may no longer be on the cutting edge of science and technology. After the last Space Shuttle flew, the United States has been totally without a way to get astronauts into orbit or to the Space Station, and there’s no rush for the USA to get Orion project moving any faster over the next few years. We have to rely on 1960s vintage Russian Soyuz launch vehicles.

This blows the whole concept of “American exceptionalism” right out of the water. Some commentators refer to the idea as if it were some kind of birthright, like just because you were born in the Lower 48 it means you’re better than everybody else on the planet. No, it just means you were lucky not to have been born in some other hellhole like Iraq or Somalia or Syria.

This nation in so many ways is the greatest place in the world. We are, however, being threatened by forces both external and internal. There are countries, free from the responsibility of maintaining our level of military preparedness, that dedicate more resources to its people and their development and well-being. There are U.S. corporations that just laugh at the concept of American exceptionalism as they ship all their jobs overseas.

But worst of all is that we’re turning into people who couldn’t care less.

John Bartus is a singer/songwriter, former Mayor of the City of Marathon, and President of the Rotary Club of Marathon. John performs Saturdays at the Key Colony Inn, Mondays at the Castaway Restaurant, and Thursdays at Sparky’s Landing!


Join Our Blast – Keys News Right to Your INBOX


  1. Thank you for your wonderful column. It’s amazing to see someone actually put this all into words. I’d thought that intelligent people had just thrown up their hands in disgust and walked away. I’ve really almost given up on this country with the arrogance, the growing and willful ignorance, the hate, the racism and the desire to move backwards. The low-education hordes are being driven by the politicians who find it to their benefit to keep the electorate stupid and full of hate and fear. I was embarrassed to be called an American during the Bush years. Now, however? I’m even more embarrassed as the low-education, racist and bigoted American crowd becomes more and more vocal.

Leave a Reply