Key West High School teacher Paula Mercer is the Monroe County School District’s 2025 Teacher of the Year. Darren Pais of Key Largo School is the Principal of the Year and Jacob Poelma of Coral Shores High School is Assistant Principal of the Year.
Each year, every school in the district chooses a teacher of the year. A selection committee then reviews applications and classroom videos from each honoree to select the district’s teacher of the year.
Paula Mercer teaches AP government and economics at Key West High School, where she also created and coaches the school’s award-winning mock trial team that has competed at the state level. She serves as the senior class sponsor and volunteers with the Special Olympics.
“Selection committee members praised her instructional video for its evidence of high-quality teaching, strong student connections and the impressive focus and participation of senior students,” states a press release from the school district.
“Mrs. Mercer represents the very best of Monroe County,” said Superintendent Edward Tierney. “Her passion for civic education, her ability to reach every learner and her commitment to building a vibrant school community make her an extraordinary educator.”
Principal of the Year: Darren Pais
Darren Pais, principal of the A-rated Key Largo School, was honored for his connection with students and staff and his commitment to strengthening academic and extracurricular programs.
“Mr. Pais is known for being everywhere on campus — greeting families in the car line, reading to students, attending nearly every school event, and walking the halls with a smile,” states the release. “His visibility and genuine care have made Key Largo School a place where students feel seen, teachers feel supported and families feel welcomed.”
Key Largo School achieved an A grade under his leadership. Pais has also revitalized athletics, strengthened community partnerships and launched popular performing arts programs. His commitment to students — academically, socially and emotionally — has transformed the school culture and increased student engagement.
Assistant Principal of the Year: Jacob Poelma
Jacob Poelma, assistant principal at Coral Shores High School, was honored for his ability to strengthen student performance and school culture.
Mr. Poelma is known for his strong relationships with students and unwavering support for teachers and families. He approaches every decision with a whole-school perspective, recognizing how each action influences student success.
A skilled data leader, Poelma creates clear, meaningful reports that help teachers and administrators make informed decisions. He supports schools across the district with data needs and develops tools that make complex information accessible and actionable.
He has also transformed Coral Shores’ testing systems, redesigning schedules, proctoring plans and testing environments to reduce disruptions and maximize instructional time.
Poelma shares resources, offers feedback, introduces new technologies and celebrates successes, fostering a culture where empowered teachers lead to empowered students.
“Jacob is the kind of leader who makes everyone around him better,” said Tierney.
