Keys softball teams made the most of the 2025 season. Key West went 16-8 after a fantastic run into the postseason that didn’t stop at a district championship. The Lady Conchs took out one team after another until reaching the elite eight of 4A softball. Almost as exciting as their district title, the Lady Conchs return a majority of their talented roster to continue their legacy of winning. Coral Shores finished the season 5-6 after going winless one year prior. The Hurricanes’ success didn’t stop with their wins; the team had the largest turnout in recent memory to fill their benches and hopes for more success to come. Marathon was 9-7 in their first season in the Rural division. The Lady Fins lose just one senior from their starting lineup, giving Middle Keys fans a lot to look forward to.
MVP
Brianna Brenner
Sophomore, Key West
Pitcher
Prep softball teams don’t make deep runs into the postseason without a dominant force in the circle, and Key West’s Brianna Brenner was just that. Brenner compiled a .750 win percentage, bringing home nine Ws for the Lady Conchs. Brenner led the district in ERA with a 2.26 and strikeouts with 127, and she has two more seasons to develop her repertoire. Head coach Jason Garcia said, “Brianna Brenner was dominant all year. She kept us in every game.” He called the sophomore slinger “a true leader on the mountain.”
Elena Eubank
Senior, Marathon
Infielder
Marathon’s Elena Eubank led the Dolphins in nearly every offensive category this season. The senior infielder earned an impressive .537 batting average, .667 on-base percentage and .829 slugging percentage. Eubank amassed 22 hits including a pair of home runs, stole 18 bases, batted in 22 runs and crossed home plate 26 times for a stellar senior season.
Madelyn Thornton
Sophomore, Marathon
Pitcher
When the Lady Fins needed a pitcher this season, Madelyn Thornton stepped into the circle. With no experience, the sophomore managed four wins and 66 strikeouts to go along with a perfect fielding percentage. Thornton’s bat was even more impressive, with a .500 average, two home runs, 28 RBIs and a .909 slugging percentage.
Sara Robinson
Sophomore, Marathon
Utility
Sophomore Sara Robinson held down multiple positions this season, stepping up for the team where they needed her most. Robinson’s play at third, behind the plate and in the circle made her indispensable as a utility player. At pitcher, she won four games for the Fins, and offensively, she scored 23 runs, one via home run, batted in 16 runs and stole 11 bases.
Maeve Merryman
Sophomore, Marathon
Catcher
Marathon sophomore Maeve Merryman’s infield play was dominant this season, illustrated by her perfect fielding percentage. Merryman’s service at catcher was reliable and her bat kept the Fins in multiple games. Merryman claimed a .444 batting average, racked up 20 hits, batted in 18 runs and stole 20 bases in her sophomore campaign.
Vera Rodger
Senior, Key West
Infielder
Senior Vera Rodger’s perfection in the field made her an asset to the Lady Conchs defensively, but it was her bat that made the greatest impact. Rodger averaged .378 with 28 hits, 20 runs and 17 RBIs this season. Her stats include eight doubles and four triples to boost her slugging percentage to .595.
Aaliyah McLeod
Freshman, Key West
Infielder
Just a freshman, Key West’s Aaliyah McLeod made a big impact for the Conchs. Her consistency on both offense and defense helped boost the team all season. McLeod averaged .292, amassing 19 hits, 14 RBIs, which included two doubles and a home run.
Shylo Sanchez
Junior, Key West
Catcher
Credited with carrying the team through the postseason with her bat, junior Shylo Sanchez finished the season batting .320 with 16 hits that included six doubles, a triple and a home run. Sanchez showed prowess defensively as well, with a .968 fielding percentage as the Lady Conchs’ catcher.
Lilee Gage
Sophomore, Key West
Infielder
Lilee Gage stepped up her game for Key West this season, batting .358 with 19 hits, 16 runs and 14 RBIs. The selective sophomore combined 10 walks with her hits for an on-base percentage of .460. Defensively, Gage finished the season with a .944 fielding percentage.
Tavyn Gage
Senior, Key West
Infielder
Tavyn Gage’s positive outlook made her an asset for the Lady Conchs this season. Described as a “total team player” by Garcia, Gage finished her senior campaign with 18 hits, 18 RBIs, eight doubles and 16 runs.
Addison Grady
Freshman, Coral Shores
Utility
Described by Hurricanes coach Kevin Williams as “a coach’s dream,” Addison Grady filled in without complaint wherever the team needed her. Whether it was playing shortstop, first base or pitcher, the freshman held it down and made the plays. Grady led the team in nearly every offensive category despite being one of the youngest on their roster.
Mira Joes
Junior, Coral Shores
Outfield
A three-year starter for the ’Canes, Mira Jones showed constant improvement in all areas of play. Jones’ detail-oriented approach and focus on being her best at all times paid off with exceptional results. Her bat came in clutch all season long, and the leadership she demonstrated earned her a role as team captain.
Chloie Stanley
Junior, Coral Shores
Infielder
Junior Chloie Stanley stood out this season for being a jack of all trades. The infielder proved to be solid in hitting, fielding and baserunning, but it is her intangibles which set her apart. Stanley won the team’s “Hurricane Award” for being a model student-athlete. Her willingness to help others and bring the fun, positive energy helped boost the ’Canes when they needed it most.
Presley Bagwell
Junior, Coral Shores
Pitcher
Presley Bagwell proved to be the missing piece to Coral Shores’ lineup this season. Starting every game for the ’Canes, Bagwell’s consistency in delivery was exactly what Coral Shores needed to secure their wins. The junior hurler was praised for her commanding presence in the circle, solid hitting and outspoken leadership.
