Most of a major water-quality restoration project for the Village of Islamorada has been completed. But part of the complex effort — to improve nearshore environmental conditions in several Lower Matecumbe Key canals — hit a snag and is not being accomplished for now, village officials said.
The Lower Matecumbe Canals network was identified with poor water quality and lack of flushing due to canal orientation.
The dead-end waterways on the project’s roster include canals 150, 151, 152, 155 and 157, on the southern end of the island, according to Peter Frezza, the village’s environmental resources manager.
Canals 150, 151, 152 and 155 have been connected by pre-fabricated concrete culverts and water is flowing. Those structures stretch underneath Sandy Cove Avenue, portions of Gulfview and Lake View drives as well as White Marlin Boulevard.
But Frezza said that an effort to horizontally drill under the Overseas Highway near MM 74, to install a pipeline connecting Florida Bay near Scouting America’s Florida Sea Base with oceanside canal 157 near Iroquois Drive, had to be abandoned.
The village first visualized the project back in 2019 and began discussing it with WSP USA Inc., the village’s contracted engineering services consultant.
LPS Contracting Inc., was awarded the $8.9 million contract for project construction. The firm successfully completed connecting the canals on the Florida Bay side of the highway.
However, Frezza said, when it came to linking the oceanside canal near Iroquois with Florida Bay at MM73.9, LPS and a subcontractor struggled with unforeseen environmental challenges that included excessive presence of hydrogen sulfate. That, and especially an expired easement agreement with Sea Base, ended current attempts to make the connection.
“Time ran out and it is disappointing,” said Frezza, about not completing the connection on both sides of the highway. “They (LPS) have refilled the tunnel with mortar and are working to restore the (Sea Base) property.
“However, both the village and LPS still desire to complete the entire project and we plan to examine alternative locations under U.S. 1 to make the connection,” he said.
Frezza said he was delighted with the remainder of the project to install a series of concrete culverts, some with steel bars to create a protective barrier to thwart the entrance of manatees and dolphins into each connection point.
He credited residents who were supportive despite being mildly affected by construction.
“We had tremendous cooperation from residents,” Frezza said. “And we had grants that fully funded the project.”
The grants came from the Florida Department of Environmental Protection and the Florida Keys Water Quality Improvement Program administered by the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers.
“The amount of life that these pipes have generated in only a short amount of time is incredible,” Frezza said. “They have turned into a zone of life within a couple months of the completion.”
Last year, a resident living on El Capitan Drive was surprised when he saw two squid swimming near the seawall in a waterway commonly referred to as the “Grand Canal.”
“There are two common (squid) species in the Keys,” said Tom Matthews, a researcher for the Florida Fish and Wildlife Conservation Commission Research Institute. “Sepioteuthis sepiodiea and Lolliguncula brevis are mostly nocturnal and not often seen.
“Squid need high oxygen levels in the water,” Matthews said. “Higher oxygen as part of high water quality promotes more species and is the likely reason why they were there.”
Frezza deems the project the most significant in his 27-year career. The village has completed 10 major water quality restoration projects and has more on tap.
“I have extreme confidence this is going to produce some very significant beneficial results,” Frezza said. “The tide does not move through these canals, so introducing these culverts allows the water to flow, which is life-giving, and that will add oxygen to the water.”
Frezza added that there is post-project research to determine results even though the canals have seen clearer water and more marine life.
“We do have a water monitoring plan in place,” he said. “We are monitoring water quality and the benthic environment, meaning the plants on the bottom of the canals and the fish life in the canals.
“We will, with time, be able to assess before and after to see how it has changed,” said Frezza.