A household name in the house business: Keys Ocean Realty marks one year in business

The Keys Ocean Realty team toasts to one year in business. From left: Riley Woodstock, Mallory Pinto and Melany Massaro. CONTRIBUTED

Everyone in Marathon knows Mallory Pinto. But she still has a problem: They don’t remember she sells real estate.

“Oh my gosh, I forget you’re a real estate agent,” she hears, usually from people who know her as a vacation rental manager, Marathon High grad and familiar face at seemingly every local event and fundraiser.

Now, she’s making it unmistakable, celebrating one year with her own brokerage, Keys Ocean Realty, to complement a vacation rental business with Keys Ocean Vacation Rentals.

Pinto entered real estate in 2016 under Joanne Cook, then with RE/MAX All Keys Real Estate. Cook remains a mentor, with the two still talking several times a week.

After a 2020 merger with Ocean Sotheby’s, Pinto also began managing vacation rentals, later purchasing Keys Ocean Vacation Rentals in 2024. Barely a year later, with several personal transactions in her pipeline, she was ready to strike out on her own, betting that in Marathon, a single agent’s reputation can do the talking.

“I’d much rather be a back-end person who’s reviewing everyone’s contracts, making sure everyone is good to go and that all the transactions are happening the right way,” she said. “When I finished my broker’s course, it was all such a fun, nerdy law side of the real estate transaction. So for me, it made sense to open my own brokerage and be able to do that.”

Her pitch is small and local, and her sweet spot is Keys residents, many of them seeking houses under $1 million – but hands-on experience running a rental company also gives her an eye for properties that may perform for second-home owners. 

She wants part of what she earns to stay in the Keys, supporting everything from women’s clubs to youth sports and theater programs.

Her first two Keys Ocean clients were family. Her mother, Monroe County Mayor Michelle Lincoln, fell hard for Marathon’s Crane Hammock neighborhood and spent months touring houses there. Pinto says it took more showings than she cared to count before a new build finally checked every box. Her mother closed in January, and Pinto then sold her old house.

Months later, another familiar connection brought Mallory back to the same neighborhood, where she sold a home belonging to longtime vacation rental clients in just 10 days.

Even in a slower real estate market, both her vacation rental business and fledgling brokerage earned finalist nods in the 2026 Best of Marathon Awards.

“I don’t think the vacation rental company has ever been nominated, and to get nominated for a real estate company legitimately less than a year in business, that was really cool,” she said.

Through changing coworkers and company ownership, Pinto has preserved relationships with friends who still refer business her way – and two who now work alongside her. With agents Riley Woodstock and Melany Massaro, she’s hoping to grow the brokerage’s volume in 2027.

Because for Pinto, the goal hasn’t been to build the biggest brokerage in town. It’s to build one that reflects the community where she grew up, while supporting agents who value the same and do business the right way.

“I’m a broker who’s here, and a broker who cares,” she said.

Alex Rickert
Alex Rickert made the perfectly natural career progression from dolphin trainer to newspaper editor in 2021 after freelancing for Keys Weekly while working full time at Dolphin Research Center. A resident of Marathon since 2015, he fell in love with the Florida Keys community by helping multiple organizations and friends rebuild in the wake of Hurricane Irma. An avid runner, actor, and spearfisherman, he spends as much of his time outside of work on or under the sea having civil disagreements with sharks.

Subscribe To Our Newsletter

Get Keys Weekly delivered right to your inbox along with a daily dose of Keys News.

Success! Please check your email for confirmation.