The city of Key West this year received $3 million in state funding to conduct a study of the College Road landfill known as Mount Trashmore.
But the city commission hadn’t specifically requested such funding and ultimately had to forgo the $3 million allocation due to a demanding timeline that required the funds to be spent and the entire study completed by June 2027.
At their Dec. 10 meeting, commissioners are expected to approve a list of next year’s legislative priorities, which will likely include an official request for the $3 million landfill study.
The study, according to an email from Todd Stoughton, the city’s director of legislative affairs, would determine:
- “What is in the landfill? Identify the materials deposited over the years, assess the environmental conditions, and determine whether soil, groundwater, surrounding waters, or other environmental conditions present potential concerns.
- “What can we do with the landfill as it exists today? Evaluate whether the property can safely remain in its current condition or accommodate public uses, including recreation, open space, trails, or other improvements, and identify what protective measures may be necessary.
- “What would be required for other future uses? Determine the environmental, regulatory, engineering, and financial requirements associated with partial or full reclamation, potential development, or other disposition of the property.”
The future of Mount Trashmore has long been a discussion for city commissioners, who for decades have debated its potential development, sale or use as parkland. But there are also concerns about the potential costs associated with identifying and exposing hazardous materials contained inside.
The $3 million funding allocation for the landfill study prompted questions from Mayor Sam Kaufman, who emphasized in multiple emails to City Manager Brian L. Barroso that the city commission had not requested the study or the funding for it. Kaufman repeatedly asked who did request the funding on behalf of the city. Did an individual, developer or other company contact the city’s lobbyists and insert the landfill study funding request on the city’s behalf?
Kaufman said at the Nov. 2 commission meeting that Stoughton had told him that a third party had requested state funding for the landfill study.
Kaufman’s concern, which was echoed in an email from commissioner Chris Massicotte to Barroso, pertained to the potential, unknown involvement of private developers or individuals inserting their own requests into the city’s legislative priorities by privately contacting Key West’s lobbyists to seek funding for projects the city commission had not prioritized.
Following a week or so of lengthy email exchanges about the history of that $3 million request, allocation and eventual forfeiture, Stoughton on Nov. 13 emailed an explanation of the funding request, writing, “Although the Mount Trashmore landfill site is not listed … within the city’s state legislative agenda, the issue falls within the broader categories of water quality and resiliency. During discussions with (state) Sen. Ana Maria Rodriguez and Senate President Ben Albritton, staff were informed that … funding may be available to support a feasibility study … for the landfill site. Based on those discussions, a $3 million appropriation request … was included in the Senate budget proposal. This funding would support evaluating long-term solutions and was initially programmed with no anticipated cost to the city.
“To clarify … my references to a third party concerned outside companies that had separately expressed interest in potential remediation of the Stock Island Landfill. I was not stating that a private individual or company contacted the Southern Group (lobbyists) to initiate or submit the city’s $3 million … request. If my prior wording created that impression, I want to correct it clearly. I am not aware of an outside third party that contacted the Southern Group specifically to request this appropriation.”
Stoughton’s email continued, “During the city’s February 2026 Tallahassee visit, Key West representatives and the Southern Group discussed the landfill with Senator Ana Maria Rodriguez and Senate President Ben Albritton. City staff was advised … that funding might be available for a feasibility study.
“Following informal discussions regarding potential landfill remediation and available funding, City Manager Brian Barroso contacted the city’s lobbying firm to pursue the opportunity, with any formal commitments, contracts or expenditures to be brought before the commission as required,” Stoughton wrote in explanation.
“Its omission from that summary (of legislative requests) was not intended to withhold the appropriation or its origin from the Commission,” Stoughton added.
The landfill will almost certainly be a topic of discussion at the Dec. 10 commission meeting, when lawmakers finalize their priorities for the upcoming legislative session in Tallahassee.