Marathon Mayor Debbie Struyf is apologizing after a hot microphone caught and live-streamed her using a vulgar slur to describe a local resident moments after the Nov. 10 city council meeting.
Shortly after the Tuesday meeting had officially concluded, city camera systems continued to broadcast a live feed from the council chambers, when local Wendy Bonilla approached the dais to question Struyf.
As Bonilla left the dais, a live microphone caught Struyf saying, “That’s Wendy, she’s a f***ing c***.”
Vice Mayor Lynny Del Gaizo, who had served as Marathon’s mayor until earlier in the same meeting, is heard laughing before alerting Struyf that her microphone was live.
While the meeting recording has yet to be posted on city video on demand channels, a cell phone recording of the stream was widely shared via social media and multiple news outlets. The clip prompted a firestorm of comments from residents in Marathon and beyond – ranging from supporting Struyf’s work as a whole on the council to calling for her resignation.
Speaking to the Weekly on Nov. 17, Bonilla said the exchange came after she had approached Struyf to ask for paperwork regarding alleged improprieties with transferable building rights within the city. Both Struyf and Bonilla said Struyf had agreed to share the documents before “the next council meeting” – which Bonilla believed to be November’s session, while Struyf had intended for December.
Bonilla said the clip, which did not include the prior interaction between the two women, was shared with her the same evening, and that she had forwarded it privately to both Struyf and Del Gaizo, waiting two days for a reply before taking to social media. Struyf apologized in a string of social media posts after the clip broke online, later texting and calling Bonilla personally.
“While I may not have liked what was said to me, I should have handled myself better,” Struyf wrote via Facebook. “In this position, more is expected of me, and I am sorry to you and the community I love.”
Fellow council members Robyn Still and Lynn Landry denounced the incident in social media posts, with Still calling the video a “sad moment for our community.”
“Whether a microphone is on or off, our citizens deserve to be treated with dignity and respect,” she wrote. “This is not reflective of the values of our city or the standards we should expect from our elected officials.”
Del Gaizo told the Weekly that her laughter was related to a personal gift received before the meeting, not Struyf’s comment, and otherwise declined to comment on the exchange.
Speaking to the Weekly by phone on Nov. 17, Struyf reiterated that she regretted her words, but had no intention of resigning her position.
“It should have never happened on any level, and there’s no excuse for what I said,” said Struyf. “I’ve apologized. I’ve sent text messages. I’ve spoken to everybody who’s called me and apologized to anybody who I speak with right off the bat. … But I’ve worked too hard to get us in this city, where changes are being made in a positive way, to step down.”
Throughout the past year, city officials have made repeated references to city resolution 2017-21, outlining proper decorum for council meetings and preventing verbal displays or targeted language aimed at individuals during city proceedings.
But speaking to the Weekly on Tuesday, City Manager Steve Williams said the resolution doesn’t apply once the gavel strikes at the close of the meeting.
“There is no enforcement mechanism outside of meetings – it does not apply to daily activity here in City Hall, or at a city park or anything else,” Williams said. “We don’t condone the behavior, and we will endeavor to do better as a city to make sure such things never happen again.”
Asked what would have happened if the comment had been made five minutes earlier, Williams said, “we would have had city guidelines and rules to deal with such an issue. There may have been potential further ramifications.”
Nearly a week removed from the controversy, Bonilla confirmed that she had received both a call and text from Struyf after the video broke on social media, but said she would still expect a public apology in the council’s next session – “live streamed, for the world to see, in the same way I was insulted.”
“We’re not allowed to clap in these meetings, but then people can speak this way?” she said. “It’s not right.”
While recordings of council meetings are usually run from “gavel to gavel,” multiple sources told the Weekly that Tuesday’s meeting was not the first time cameras and/or microphones had been left on for short periods following the meeting.
The Weekly has requested a copy of all footage recorded by city cameras and microphones during the meeting, up to and including the interaction between Struyf and Bonilla.
The council agreed to cancel its November and December workshop sessions due to upcoming holidays. The next regular meeting is set for Tuesday, Dec. 8 at 5:30 p.m. at Marathon City Hall.