Functionally Caffeinated Wellness: Thanksgiving dinner isn’t a medical emergency

Thanksgiving dinner should be enjoyed with loved ones, not atoned for due to its caloric content. Enjoy the holiday AND the meal. CONTRIBUTED

Every November, like clockwork, the health and wellness industry begins its annual campaign to convince us that Thanksgiving dinner is something we need to survive. Not enjoy. Not celebrate. Survive. Suddenly, my inbox is filled with helpful little articles about how to avoid holiday weight gain, how to make mashed potatoes without potatoes, and how many miles I’ll need to run to burn off a slice of pumpkin pie. I’m sorry, but when did Thanksgiving become a hostage situation?

Somewhere along the way, we decided that sitting down with people we love and enjoying a meal that someone probably spent the better part of two days preparing was a threat to our health. We started using words like “cheat,” “guilt” and “damage control” to describe eating stuffing. STUFFING. A food that makes an appearance approximately twice a year, and apparently, we need a strategic defense plan to consume it.

As an exercise physiologist and nutrition coach, I spend a considerable amount of my professional life helping people understand how their bodies work. And I can assure you that the human body is remarkably well equipped to handle Thanksgiving dinner. In fact, digestion is something it does every single day. Without requiring a detox tea, a 48-hour fast or a workout titled “Burn Off the Bird.”

Let’s talk about what actually happens when you eat a larger-than-usual meal, because I think a little physiology might help everyone relax.

First, your stomach expands. That’s literally part of its job. Your digestive system releases enzymes, your pancreas produces insulin in response to rising blood glucose, and your body begins breaking down and absorbing nutrients. Some of that energy gets used immediately and some gets stored for later. Nothing about this process is particularly alarming. Your body doesn’t look at a second helping of sweet potato casserole and sound an emergency alarm.

Now, you might feel a little sleepy afterward. And before someone blames the turkey, let’s clear up one of my favorite Thanksgiving myths. Yes, turkey contains tryptophan, an amino acid involved in the production of serotonin and melatonin. But turkey isn’t unique in that department, and the amount you consume at Thanksgiving isn’t likely to single-handedly knock you unconscious. A large meal, carbohydrates, alcohol, your normal sleep patterns and the fact that you’ve been sitting around for several hours all contribute to that post-dinner desire to become one with the couch. Turkey has been unfairly prosecuted for decades.

Then comes Friday morning. The day when some people make the unfortunate decision to step on a scale and immediately question every choice they made the previous afternoon.

Let’s say the number is three pounds higher than it was Wednesday. Before you start calculating how many burpees it takes to reverse a dinner roll, understand that a temporary increase in body weight does not automatically mean you’ve gained three pounds of body fat. Carbohydrates help replenish glycogen stores, and glycogen is stored with water. Sodium can temporarily increase fluid retention. And yes, some of the food you ate is quite literally still inside your digestive system. Fascinating, isn’t it? Your body has not violated the laws of physics. It’s just doing its job.

Of course, regularly consuming more energy than your body needs can lead to increased body fat over time. I’m not going to pretend otherwise. But one holiday meal doesn’t tell us much about someone’s overall health, just as one salad doesn’t magically erase months of poor nutrition. Health is built through patterns, not isolated performances.

Which brings me to the Thanksgiving morning turkey trot. I love a good holiday race. I love seeing families walking together, people wearing ridiculous turkey costumes and communities coming together around movement. What I don’t love is the idea that you need to run five miles to earn the right to eat dinner.

Since when did exercise become a payment plan for food?

Physical activity improves cardiovascular health, supports muscle and bone strength, helps regulate blood glucose and offers tremendous benefits for our brains. Those benefits exist whether you eat pumpkin pie afterward or not. You don’t need to justify eating by exercising, and you certainly don’t need to punish yourself with an extra workout on Friday because you enjoyed Thursday.

The same goes for the post-holiday detox. Every year, we’re encouraged to cleanse our bodies after Thanksgiving, as though our internal organs collectively took the holiday off. Your liver and kidneys are working around the clock, including while you’re reaching for leftover pie. Unless you have an actual medical condition requiring specific dietary management, you probably don’t need a special cleanse. You need to return to your usual routine, drink some water, move your body and allow your digestive system to do what it was designed to do.

Here’s what bothers me most about the way we’ve turned Thanksgiving into a nutritional obstacle course. We’ve become so focused on what food does to our bodies that we sometimes forget what food contributes to our lives.

Food is more than carbohydrates, fats and protein. It’s culture. It’s tradition. It’s the recipe written on an index card in someone’s handwriting. It’s the dish your grandmother made that nobody has quite figured out how to replicate. It’s the person who insists on bringing the same questionable casserole every single year, and the rest of the family politely pretending to be excited about it.

Those experiences matter, too. Sharing meals can strengthen social connections, create memories and give us opportunities to slow down in a world that seems increasingly determined to move at warp speed. I think we could all benefit from a little more of that.

Now, this doesn’t mean abandoning common sense. If you have diabetes, food allergies, digestive conditions or other medical considerations, those don’t magically disappear because it’s Thanksgiving. You can honor your health needs and still participate in the celebration. The two are not mutually exclusive.

What I am suggesting is that we stop treating one meal as though it has the power to undo everything we’ve worked toward.

So this Thanksgiving, eat the mashed potatoes. The real ones, with butter. Have some stuffing. Enjoy the pie if you want it. Take a walk because the weather is beautiful or because you need a break from your relatives, not because your fitness tracker has informed you that you’re in caloric debt.

And when Friday morning arrives, please don’t turn your holiday memories into a mathematical equation involving calories, guilt and punishment. Get back to the habits that support your health. That’s it. No dramatic comeback required.

Thanksgiving dinner is not a medical emergency. It’s dinner. A particularly delicious one, if we’re lucky.

And for the love of all things pumpkin, can we please stop trying to make cauliflower taste like mashed potatoes?

Jennifer Boltz-Harvey
Jennifer Boltz-Harvey is the owner and operator of Highly Motivated Functionally Caffeinated, LLC, a concierge personal training and nutrition coaching business in the Keys. Her passions include helping people reach their health goals as well as working out, cooking and traveling with her husband. She also really loves snuggles from her dog, Stella.

Subscribe To Our Newsletter

Get Keys Weekly delivered right to your inbox along with a daily dose of Keys News.

Success! Please check your email for confirmation.